[Beta] Midihub 1.14.1 Inconsistent Drag Pipeline to 2nd Editor

This might be just a Mac issue so it would be useful if others in the community could test it briefly on Linux & Windows.

This (fairly meaningless) preset CopyPasteDuplicate.mhp was made in one Editor instance, by dragging pipes and pipelines to duplicate them.

Everything worked as expected.


I then opened a 2nd Editor instance…

on Mac OS X

by pasting this into Terminal

/Applications/Midihub\ Editor.app/Contents/MacOS/Midihub\ Editor ; exit;

(I think you only have to do this on Mac)

…and started with a new blank preset.

Here dragging (from the file above in the 1st Editor) caused inconsistencies:

Original Transforms
L1: (Note_on,Inside), (Note_on,Outside), (CC,Inside),
L2: (Note_on,Inside), (Note_on,Outside), (CC,Inside), (Note_on,Outside)
L3: As L1

(L2&3 created by [shift]-alt-dragging L1. All as expected)

1st attempt dragging to new file
CopyPasteDuplicatedToSepEditor.mhp
screenshot (source below, destination above):

  • L1: alt-drag Original L1: loses Transform1
    becomes (Note_on,Outside), (CC,Inside)

  • L2: shift-alt-drag Original L1: Barmy!
    (Note_on,Outside), (CC,Inside),(Note_on,Outside Mapped)

  • L3 shift-alt-drag Original L1:OK

  • L4 alt-drag Original L2:“OK”
    but note Mappings copied even though Shift not down

Second attempt
CopyPasteDuplicatedToSepEditor2.mhp

  • L1 as First attempt

  • All other pipes copy from Original but without mappings irrespective of drag-mode.


can anyone else replicate similar inconsistencies?

PS. I don’t think I tested this with earlier versions, @Giedrius, so apologies if I could’ve picked it sooner!

Confirmed!

when i use this file ,or just new file

even with one instance of MIDIHUB Editor ,
when i drag pipeline by the first MIDI PORT pipe while holding ALT to duplicate
after few times editor starts to cut pipes
this behaviour is inconsistent


Thank you, will be fixed in the next minor update.

Excellent. I discovered bug while creating a short pictorial guide to dragging and dropping, so I’ll finish that after update…